"SEIU Protest", by Spot Us, CC BY-SA 2.0
This piece was originally published by the Aspen Institute.
Every day, millions of American workers play by rules they never wrote, rules that all too often fail to consider the human aspect of work. The home care worker whose algorithm-assigned schedule leaves no time between clients. The security guard whose digital tracker penalizes bathroom breaks. The worker whose employer uses surveillance tools to identify workplace organizing and illegally retaliates against them for exercising their legal right to form a union. The warehouse worker whose pace of work is set by software with no regard for their health or safety.
These aren’t just isolated problems—they’re the predictable outcome of a system where those writing the rules have deliberately excluded the people who must live by them. At this ten-year mark of debate and discussion about the future of work, perhaps the most important thing we can address with hindsight is that, while technology can and has replaced some jobs, it has also profoundly shifted power dynamics and control in the workplace, as technology co-opts worker agency and autonomy, intensifies work, and minimizes recourse. As this trend accelerates with the growing use of AI, we must create spaces for worker-led technology adoption that treats human beings with respect and dignity.
The 2 million members of the Service Employees International Union who I represent—caregivers, janitors, public service workers, airport staff, security officers, and hospital employees–are the people who keep this country running. They clean planes, care for your grandmother, protect city buildings, and make sure our hospitals and schools serve all of us. They do essential work—work rooted in judgment, care, and connection.
Rather than using technology to undermine agency in the workplace, employers and policy-makers have the opportunity to instead use it to support these vital workers. To achieve a future in which workers are prepared and empowered to leverage technology to their benefit, SEIU is advancing an agenda that includes: sector-wide bargaining to establish minimum standards; prohibition on AI discipline; protecting worker rights to override automated systems; full transparency in data collection; and meaningful retraining when technology transforms jobs.
Because here’s what we know: when working people unite to demand new rules, we’ve never lost a fight we were determined to win.
Jernej Furman from Slovenia, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons
Rules Rigged By Design
A decade ago, we didn’t fully grasp how profoundly technology would reshape the workplace—not just by automating tasks, but by transforming decision-making, shifting control, and accelerating the breakdown of traditional employment relationships. We believed that tools like retraining or reskilling would be enough to help workers adapt. But those tools were designed for a different kind of disruption. They can’t match the scale or speed at which algorithms now make invisible decisions about schedules, pay, and performance—or the way AI enables corporations to further fracture responsibility through subcontracting and app-based control. The threat isn’t just lost jobs. It’s lost agency.
This impact extends to sectors across our economy. In hospitals, AI systems are used to make staffing and patient care decisions that experienced nurses say often prioritize efficiency over quality care. In home care, algorithms slash service hours for vulnerable clients based on rigid formulas that ignore human needs. In security and janitorial work, companies implement gamified tracking apps that treat essential workers like pieces on a digital game board rather than skilled professionals.
Let’s be honest about what’s happening: the rules governing work in America have always been tilted against certain communities. For generations, this country’s economic rulebook has treated Black and brown labor as disposable, women’s work as less valuable, and immigrant contributions as exploitable.
Technology hasn’t changed these rules—it’s just digitized them. Algorithms don’t make neutral decisions; they encode and amplify existing biases, transforming historical discrimination into automated policy. The rules might look different, but the outcomes remain painfully familiar.
The uncomfortable reality is that technology isn’t neutral. It inevitably reflects the values and biases of those who design it. When those values are rooted in inequality and profit at all costs, the outcomes will naturally follow suit—widening divides rather than closing them.
The Path Forward: Collective Action
So how do we break this cycle? Through organizing, legislation, and holding power to account—the time-tested tools that have always driven progress.
At SEIU, we firmly believe workers deserve a meaningful voice in how technology affects their livelihoods. We’ve seen promising examples of what’s possible. In Pennsylvania, Governor Josh Shapiro’s administration partnered with our members—state employees with SEIU Local 668—to establish a Generative AI Labor and Management Collaboration Group. Together, they’re developing ethical AI guidelines with workers at the table. This collaborative approach represents what shared power looks like in practice.
In fact, time and again unionization and collective bargaining has shown itself to be key to ensuring that employers introduce new technology in collaboration with employees and unions, and that workers are protected from, or compensated for, impacts to their jobs. Unions have also successfully negotiated with employers over surveillance, pace of work, and discipline by AI.[1]
But we need more than contract by contract successes—we need enforceable standards across the board. That’s why we’re advancing a comprehensive agenda:
First, we need to enact legislation to strengthen workers’ ability to form unions and bargain collectively. We need sector-wide bargaining to establish uniform workplace standards across industries. This creates a foundation of dignity and effective collaboration that prevents the race to the bottom, closes loopholes for bad actors, and ensures basic protections for every worker regardless of individual employer.
Second, we must prohibit discipline by AI. Every worker deserves human judgment, and a grievance procedure to appeal algorithmic decisions—not automated dictates—when facing discipline or termination. The stakes are too high for algorithms to make these life-altering calls.
Third, workers need the right to override AI instructions and automated systems. In safety-critical roles especially, human judgment must take precedence, even when it means challenging an algorithm’s recommendation. Experience and context matter. And there must be safeguards against simply using humans as rubber stamps or, worse, liability shields that protect the automated systems.
Fourth, we demand full transparency regarding data collected and algorithms used by employers. When companies deploy AI systems, they must disclose exactly what worker information they gather, how they use it, and why. They must also disclose any AI decision-making authority that impacts workers.
Finally, when AI changes the nature of a job, employers must invest in worker-centered job redesign and provide real opportunities for upskilling workers to work alongside technology—developed with worker input and advice.
Let’s be candid: the corporations building these systems won’t voluntarily limit their power. Their focus will remain on maximizing shareholder value—unless we create countervailing forces through bold public policy, strong unions, and a labor movement ready to challenge both Silicon Valley and Wall Street.
David James Henry, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons
This Is About Power — And Our Collective Future
At its core, the future of work isn’t a technological question. It’s a question of power.
Who holds it. Who lacks it. And who gets to decide.
Right now, AI and algorithmic management are concentrating unprecedented control at the top while systematically disempowering everyone else. But this outcome isn’t inevitable. We can build an alternative future where technology enhances rather than diminishes human work. Where working people participate as decision-makers, not mere data points. Where care, connection, and community take priority over profit margins and efficiency metrics.
This better future won’t arrive on its own. We must organize for it with determination and purpose.
The good news? Working people know exactly how to fight for what’s right. We’ve done it throughout history—in textile mills and coal mines, in fast food restaurants and hospital break rooms. And we’re doing it now in the age of AI and algorithms.
Because here’s the fundamental truth no algorithm can calculate: what happens when millions of working people stand together, speak with one voice, and demand the dignity and respect they deserve.
The future of work is still being written. Let’s make sure it works for all of us.
[1] https://www.americanprogress.org/article/unions-give-workers-a-voice-over-how-ai-affects-their-jobs/
.jpg){kind=link}
